Hi Kath, My overall favourite has to be the BullyMoon all white suit etched markings one, followed by the green dot Papa.
Arno's rare Papa with the 2nd old emblem variation is also a favourite... although it hasn't arrived yet
I've gone through my years favourites and have put them in number order rather than rarity/favourite, etc..., not as many as in previous years, but here they are:
20101 Papa Smurf, Old Emblem- (Arno’s rare one)
20101- Papa Smurf, green dot.
20101- Papa Smurf, Hong Kong. W.Berrie, black dot.
20003- Bully Astro, white suit, hand etched marking
20003- Astro, New Emblem
20006- Brainy, Old emblem, Big eyes
20008- Spy, peyo/ Schleich on back of legs
20017- Mirror “made in Hong Kong/painted in Sri Lanka”
20040- Gift and Flowers, green dot
20054- First Aid, yellow bag, W.Germany, black dot
20065- Rugby, Portugal, smooth base
20072- Trumpet, removed Bully, no dot.
20072- Trumpet, removed Bully, mustard dot
20074- King, Bully, black dot
20078- Beer, Bully, black dot
20083- Hammer, Schleich, mustard dot
20085- Cushion, Schleich, no dot
20086- Gift, Bully, green dot
20090- Jester, Schleich, no dot
20090- Jester, new Schleich marking, red dot
20090- Jester, new Schleich marking, black dot
20092- Papa Conductor, Bully, white dot
20098- Ballerina “made in Hong Kong/painted in Sri Lanka”
20100- Cake, Schleich, black dot.
20100- Cake, Schleich, 1977, mustard dot
20110- Hairdresser, Bully, reversed colours
20121- Iceskater, Schleich, mustard dot
20122- Cowboy, China, medium CE
20133- Hockey, German National team colours
20134- Judo, China, medium CE
20135- Tennis Smurfette, IMPS
20203- Blue Baby, CE, black dot
20209- Dentist, black dot
20213- Devil, one CE, black dot.
20402- Slouchy, W.Germany, CE, no dot.
20408- Nanny, W.Germany, black dot
cheers, Tommo